Nope, that’s not a typo, and this is not a baseball post. The timing is quite coincidental.*
One of the (many) eternal debates in writing circles is “first- versus third-person narrators.” It says nothing that proposing this topic as a conversation starter will like as not lead to a small-scale riot within fifteen minutes. (Pretty much any conversation about writing, among writers, is likely to start a small-scale riot within fifteen minutes, ten if alcohol is available.) At the same time, it does rank right up there with “Should I write novels or short stories?” and the granddaddy of them all, “Should I submit to markets run by people whose politics I disagree with?” (Which often gets sidetracked by “Is it really bad to end a sentence with a preposition?”–an argument sure to end in blood. And don’t ever mention the words “Oxford comma” in a roomful of writers!)
But I digress. Although I haven’t conducted a study, it is my impression that the first-person novel is frowned upon today. Personally, I often write in the first person (like now). For me, first-person narration makes it easier to get into my character’s head. Some would question the need for this, since the protagonist is often an idealized form of the writer, but for me, it allows a freedom of expression, because the narrator, through his words, is informing the reader about himself.
Normally, an author will show the reader the narrator’s character and motivations through his actions, and his reactions. I prefer a more direct route, a more personal path. Perhaps this is because I am a science fiction writer, and my narrators are not always people you could meet on the street, or if they are, they are in extraordinary circumstances and I am interested in seeing how they respond, from the inside. (Hey, if I’m not interested, you certainly won’t be.)
Sometimes, my narrator isn’t even a person: In my latest novel, my narrator is a gorilla. How does one get into the point of view of a gorilla unless one becomes a gorilla? (In a manner of speaking.) There is no guarantee I will succeed–although I challenge anyone to tell me I failed–but I can’t think of a better way to try than with first-person narration.
It’s not true in every story, of course; I’ve written a lot of traditional third-person narratives. For me the choice comes at the beginning of the story, and generally it comes upon me already decided; I don’t choose how I’m going to tell the story because most stories choose it for themselves.
As with all of these controversies, it boils down to what’s right for the story, first- or third- person. I don’t have a preference.
Except second-person narration. Then we have a problem. And don’t even get me started on novels told in the present tense…
*Nevertheless, go Dodgers!
#SFWApro
Read Full Post »